Finelyst
Language EN

Fundraising

Startup Valuation Methods: How to Value a Startup

TL;DR

How to value a startup: Berkus, scorecard, VC method, revenue multiples and working back from the round, with a worked example and what calculators can't do.

min read
10
words
1,908
Published

You cannot calculate the value of a young startup the way you would value a property. There are no stable profits and no comparable sales, so the valuation is negotiated between founders and investors and sanity-checked with several methods: working back from the amount raised and the stake sold, the Berkus and scorecard methods before revenue, and the venture capital method and revenue multiples at later stages. Each method gives a different number. What is useful is the range that results, and knowing which assumption drives which number.

This guide explains the common methods, runs them on one hypothetical example and shows what a valuation calculator can and cannot do.

Why there is no "correct" startup valuation

Classic business valuation works with future surpluses derived from past results. A startup does not have that past. Three things follow:

  • The valuation is a price, not an appraisal. It is the number both sides agree on for this round.
  • It depends on the round. Investors often think in ownership: what percentage do they get for their money, and is that enough for the return they need?
  • It is only one part of the deal. Liquidation preferences, the option pool and other terms change what the number is worth to you.

When a term sheet says "valuation", it almost always means the pre-money or post-money valuation. The difference and the formulas are covered in pre-money vs post-money valuation.

The methods at a glance

Method Typical stage What you need Main weakness
Working back from the round Pre-seed to Series A Capital needed and target stake Describes the deal, not the "value"
Berkus method Pre-revenue A judgement on five risk areas Fixed caps, highly subjective
Scorecard method Pre-revenue or just after Comparable valuations from your region Comparable data is hard to get
Venture capital method Seed to Series A Exit assumption and target return Extremely sensitive to assumptions
Multiples Once revenue recurs Revenue or ARR and comparable multiples Multiples move with market and growth
DCF Later stages A reliable multi-year plan False precision at an early stage

Method 1: working back from capital needed and stake

The most common "method" in practice is not a valuation in the strict sense. You decide how much money you need to reach the next milestone and what stake you are willing to sell for it. The valuation follows:

  • Post-money valuation = investment ÷ investor's stake
  • Pre-money valuation = post-money valuation − investment

Hypothetical example: you need €800,000 and want to sell 20%. Post-money = €800,000 ÷ 20% = €4.0M, pre-money = €3.2M. The pre-money valuation calculator lets you try different combinations in seconds.

The value of this approach is its honesty: it shows that round size, stake and valuation are tied together. How much founders typically sell in early rounds, and why, is covered in how much equity to give up in a seed round.

Method 2: the Berkus method

Angel investor Dave Berkus developed a simple method for pre-revenue companies in the mid-1990s. It assigns an amount to each of five elements that reduce a specific risk. In his own description, that is up to $500,000 per element:

Element Risk it reduces
Sound idea Basic value, product risk
Prototype Technology risk
Quality management team Execution risk
Strategic relationships Market and competitive risk
Product rollout or sales Financial or production risk

Berkus gives a ceiling of $2 million pre-revenue and $2.5 million after product rollout, and stresses that the amounts are maximums and guides that investors adjust. Once a company has been making revenue for some time, he explicitly considers the method no longer applicable.

For you, the Berkus method is a checklist of which risks you have already removed, not a price tag. The dollar amounts come from the US angel market and do not transfer one to one to other countries and periods.

Method 3: the scorecard method

The scorecard method, which goes back to angel investor Bill Payne, does not start from zero. It starts from a reference number: the typical pre-money valuation of similar startups in the same region and stage. Your startup is then compared with that average across several categories, such as team, market size, product and technology, competitive environment, sales and partnerships, and the need for further funding. Each category has a weight; an above-average team raises the factor, a weak sales approach lowers it.

The result is an overall factor, for example 1.10, which is multiplied by the reference valuation. The method is only as good as that reference. The most reliable data on valuations in your region comes from angel networks, other founders and your own investor conversations, not from generic tables online.

Method 4: the venture capital method

The venture capital method was described in a Harvard Business School note in 1987. It works backwards from the exit:

  1. Estimate the company's value at an exit some years from now.
  2. Divide it by the multiple the investor wants to earn on the money. That gives today's post-money valuation.
  3. Account for dilution from later rounds.
  4. Subtract the investment to get the pre-money valuation.

The method shows how investors think: not every investment works out, so each one needs a shot at a high multiple. It also shows its own weakness. Double the assumed exit value and the valuation doubles; the assumption decides everything.

Method 5: revenue or ARR multiples

Once revenue recurs, valuations are often discussed as multiples: valuation = revenue or ARR × multiple. The multiple is derived from comparable funding rounds or company sales.

Three points to keep in mind:

  • Multiples depend heavily on growth, gross margin, retention and the state of the market. A multiple quoted without those is meaningless.
  • Check the base: current ARR, trailing twelve months of revenue and forecast revenue give very different numbers.
  • The international IPEV Valuation Guidelines, which funds use to report their holdings at fair value, also treat multiples as one technique among several and expect the result to be checked against market evidence.

The metrics investors look at alongside revenue are covered in startup financial metrics.

DCF and valuations for tax purposes

A discounted cash flow model discounts planned surpluses to today. For mature companies it is standard. For a startup without a reliable plan it mostly produces false precision, because small changes in growth and discount rate multiply the result.

Formal valuations still matter in one place: tax. The price of a funding round is not automatically the value the tax authority uses for shares or options. In the United States, the exercise price of stock options is normally set against a fair market value determined under the Section 409A rules, where an independent appraisal no more than twelve months old is presumed reasonable. In the United Kingdom, HMRC's Shares and Assets Valuation manual sets out how the tax authority approaches the value of unquoted shares. Other countries have their own rules. This belongs with your tax adviser or lawyer, not in a spreadsheet.

Worked example: five methods, one startup

A hypothetical B2B SaaS startup has three founders, a finished product, €15,000 of monthly recurring revenue (€180,000 ARR) and is looking for €800,000. All assumptions are invented and only illustrate the calculations.

Method Assumptions Calculation Pre-money
Working back €800,000 for 20% 800,000 ÷ 0.20 = €4.0M post-money €3.2M
Scorecard Reference valuation €3.0M, overall factor 1.10 €3.0M × 1.10 €3.3M
VC method Exit of €40M in six years, target multiple 10, 40% later dilution 40 ÷ 10 = €4.0M; × 0.6 = €2.4M post-money €1.6M
ARR multiple €180,000 ARR, assumed multiple of 12 €180,000 × 12 €2.16M
Berkus (for comparison) $300,000 + $400,000 + $350,000 + $150,000 + $300,000 Sum of the five elements $1.5M

The range runs from €1.6M to €3.3M. That is not a flaw in the methods; it is the actual information. The VC method shows the most an investor with a high return target wants to pay; working back and the scorecard show what might be usual for comparable rounds. The negotiation happens in between. The Berkus row is only there for comparison, because its author does not intend the method for a company with ongoing revenue.

To see what each valuation means for your stake after this round and the next, run it through the dilution calculator.

What a valuation calculator can and cannot do

Many founders look for a calculator that outputs the company's value. A calculator can:

  • derive pre-money and post-money valuation from investment and stake,
  • show how an option pool and convertible notes change your ownership,
  • put scenarios side by side.

It cannot know how good your team is, how large your market will really become or how many investors are competing for your round. Any number a tool produces without that information is an assumption in disguise. Use calculators to run your own assumptions, not to justify a number.

Common mistakes

Treating one method as the truth. Each method lights up one aspect. Run at least two and talk about the range.

Maximising valuation and ignoring terms. A high valuation with a heavy liquidation preference can be worse for you than a moderate one with clean terms.

Starting too high. This round's valuation is the bar for the next one. If you do not grow into it, a down round follows.

Copying comparables without context. Valuations from other countries, sectors or market phases rarely fit your situation.

Forgetting tax. The price of a round can affect how shares and employee options are valued for tax.

Checklist before you talk to investors

  • Capital needed to the next milestone calculated, with a buffer
  • Target stake for this round set and a range modelled
  • At least two methods applied, with the assumptions written down
  • Comparable rounds from your own region and stage researched
  • Your ownership after this round and the next one modelled
  • Terms beyond the valuation checked: pool, preferences, control rights
  • Tax questions raised with your adviser

How valuation fits into the full process of a round is covered in the startup fundraising guide.

Sources

This article is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. All numerical examples are hypothetical. Have the valuation, the terms and the tax consequences of a funding round reviewed by a qualified lawyer and tax adviser.

FAQ

How do you calculate the valuation of a startup?

There is no single formula. At an early stage the valuation is negotiated and sanity-checked with several methods: working back from the amount raised and the stake sold, the Berkus and scorecard methods before meaningful revenue, and the venture capital method and revenue multiples later. The result is a range, not an exact value.

Which valuation method fits a pre-revenue startup?

Before revenue, angel investors often use qualitative methods such as the Berkus or scorecard method. They assess the team, idea, prototype, market and early relationships instead of financial metrics. Working back from the capital you need and the stake you are willing to sell is a useful cross-check.

Can an online calculator tell me what my startup is worth?

No. A calculator can run assumptions cleanly, for example deriving the pre-money valuation from the investment and the stake. The assumptions themselves, such as exit value, multiple or risk discounts, remain estimates and a matter of negotiation.

Is the valuation of a funding round the same as the value used for tax?

Not automatically. Tax valuations follow their own rules. In the US, for example, option exercise prices are usually set against a separate Section 409A valuation. Ask a tax adviser how a round affects share and option valuations in your country.